I have some new cat they love one ate it the other played with it before eat it

My dog loves these. They are dry so don’t make a smelly mess. Some flakes will come off but it is easy to vacuum up. They smell strong but worth that for the dogs enjoyment. They are a simple whole food treat that is healthy for my dog. Good quality. They are solid but easy for the dog to eat. Not chewy.

These have become a favorite snack for my dogs. They love crunching on the freeze dried fish and I love that it's a healthy single ingredient treat for them.

They literally ripped open the bag.

My cat had absolutely zero interest in these. None whatsoever. I may as well have been holding cardboard or glass up to nose. So I gave them to my friend who has a Bengal. That cat liked them at first, but then changed his mind.So at the very least, this isn't a sure thing. Also, these are very fishy (unsurprisingly), and they're dried so they flake. So they can be messy.